ENTRÉES
Served with your choice of whipped potatoes, baked potato, hand-cut fries, potato peels, hash browns, seasonal vegetables, & soup or salad
Salad dressings - celery seed, blue cheese, peppercorn ranch, balsamic, 1000 island, sesame ginger, French
STEAKS
*6oz. TENDERLOIN 42 (gf)
*8oz. TENDERLOIN 49 (gf)
*14oz RIBEYE 48 (gf)
*8oz TOP SIRLOIN 27 (gf)
*6oz BAVETTE 22 (gf)
STEAK ADDITIONS
LOBSTER OSCAR $17
PARMESAN & GARLIC ENCRUSTED $3
HORSERADISH CRUST $3
SAUTEED MUSHROOMS & ONIONS $4
SEAFOOD
BROILED (special butter and wine sauce), DEEP FRIED, or PAN SEARED
HADDOCK $20
SHRIMP $22
FRESH SCALLOPS $35
GREAT LAKES WALLEYE $27
FISHERMAN’S BONANZA (haddock, shrimp, Great Lakes walleye & scallops) $37
STUFFED HADDOCK
(with seafood stuffing) $23
SHRIMP AND SCALLOPS $32
SIMPSON’S SURF & TURF COMBINATIONS
*6oz FILET MIGNON SHRIMP $52
FRESH SCALLOPS $61
HADDOCK $51
GREAT LAKES WALLEYE $54
SIMPSON’S LOBSTER DINNERS
ONE 4oz LOBSTER TAIL $36 or TWO 4oz TAILS $67
6ozFilet Mignon & Lobster Combo $67
8oz Filet Mignon & Lobster Combo $74
ADD A LOBSTER TO ANY DINNER $35
FAVORITES
Served with soup or salad
MEATBALLS & BURRATA $22
House-made meatballs, burrata cheese, fresh tomato sauce, basil oil, handmade spaghetti
BAVETTE STEAK & LOBSTER OSCAR $39
6oz bavette steak, lobster medallions, asparagus, whipped potatoes, sauce bearnaise
DUCK RISOTTO $27
Duck confit, spring vegetable risotto, Door County dried cherries, port wine reduction
PARMESAN-CRUSTED WHITEFISH $23
Parmesan-crusted fresh Canadian whitefish, asparagus, crispy potatoes, smoked tomato aioli
PASTA PRIMAVERA $20
Spring vegetables, fresh herbs, tomato sauce, Parmesan cheese, handmade spaghetti
PORK SCHNITZEL $21
Crispy pork cutlets, pickled red cabbage, brown butter spaetzle, caraway seed mustard
*RARE AHI TUNA STEAK WITH A 12 PEPPER BLEND $27
Tuna steak seared rare with a 12-pepper blend, avocado, sesame ginger coleslaw, wasabi aioli, & spicy chili lime sauce
APPETIZERS
HOUSE-MADE MEATBALLS with fresh tomato basil sauce $15
BURRATA CAPRESE with avocado, tomato, Parmesan crisp, basil oil, balsamic $16
HAND CUT TRUFFLE FRIES with bearnaise sauce $11
SMOKED WHITEFISH DIP with crackers, fresh & pickled vegetables $16
STAR DAIRY CHEESE CURDS with peppercorn ranch $12
CRAB RANGOONS with spicy chili lime sauce $12
*RARE AHI TUNA 12 pepper blend with avocado, chili sauce, and wasabi aioli $16
FRENCH ONION SOUP $10
SALADS
Add: Chicken $7
6oz Bavette Steak $18
Shrimp $8
Pepper-Crusted Ahi Tuna $9
ARUGULA BEET SALAD $15
Arugula, beets, goat cheese, pistachios, honey shallot vinaigrette
WEDGE SALAD full $16 or half $10
Iceberg, bacon, cherry tomatoes, hard-boiled egg, blue cheese crumbles, blue cheese dressing
COBB SALAD full $17 or half $11
Chicken breast, avocado, hard-boiled egg, bacon, tomato, blue cheese crumbles, peppercorn ranch
BLUECHEESE STEAK SALAD $23
6oz bavette steak, chimichurri, candied pistachios, blue cheese crumbles, red onion, blue cheese dressing
SANDWICHES
PASTRAMI REUBEN $17
House-made pastrami, pickled red cabbage, Swiss cheese, 1000 island, marble rye, hand-cut fries
FRIED CHICKEN, BACON, & RANCH $14
Fried chicken breast, bacon, Swiss cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing, hand-cut fries
FISH ON A BUN $14
Breaded haddock, tomato, shredded lettuce, tartar sauce, hand-cut fries
*SIMPSON‘S ½# BURGER $14
Shredded lettuce, tomato, red onion, secret sauce, hand-cut fries
Add - Wisconsin cheddar, applewood smoked bacon, avocado, sautéed mushrooms, or grilled onions $1
PRIME RIB FRENCH DIP $18
Shaved prime rib, Swiss cheese, French bread, hand-cut fries
SIMPSON’S TO GO PINTS
COCKTAIL MUSHROOMS $11
SEASONED FLOUR $6
SALAD DRESSINGS $8
GARLIC SPREAD $16
FRESH HORSERADISH $16
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
(GF) indicates gluten-free. A 20% gratuity will be added to parties of 10 or more corkage & cakeage $10
ENTRÉES
Served with your choice of whipped potatoes, baked potato, hand-cut fries, potato peels, hash browns, seasonal vegetables, & soup or salad
Salad dressings- celery seed, blue cheese, peppercorn ranch, balsamic, 1000 island, sesame ginger, French
STEAKS
*6oz. FILET MIGNON 43 *8oz. FILET MIGNON 50 *16oz FILET MIGNON 98
*8oz TOP SIRLOIN 28 *14oz RIBEYE 49
STEAK ADDITIONS
SAUTEED MUSHROOMS 2 SAUTEED MUSHROOMS 2
HORSERADISH CRUST 4 PARMESAN & GARLIC ENCRUSTED 4
SEAFOOD
BROILED (special butter and wine sauce), DEEP FRIED, or PAN SEARED
HADDOCK 21 SHRIMP 23 FRESH SCALLOPS 36 GREAT PERCH 29
FISHERMAN’S BONANZA (haddock, shrimp, Great Lakes perch & scallops) 38
STUFFED HADDOCK (with seafood stuffing) 24
SHRIMP AND SCALLOPS 33
SIMPSON’S SURF & TURF COMBINATIONS
*6oz FILET MIGNON
SHRIMP 54 FRESH SCALLOPS 63 HADDOCK 53 GREAT LAKES PERCH 56
SIMPSON’S LOBSTER DINNERS
ONE 4oz LOBSTER TAIL 37 or TWO 4oz TAILS 68
*6oz Filet Mignon & Lobster Combo 69
*8oz Filet Mignon & Lobster Combo 76
ADD A LOBSTER TO ANY DINNER 36
FAVORITES
Served with soup or salad
SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS 22
House-made meatballs, fresh tomato sauce, basil oil, Parmesan cheese, handmade spaghetti
MARSALA BRAISED ZEALAND LAMB SHANK 29
New Zealand lamb shank, mushrooms, whipped potatoes, Marsala jus
SMOKED CHICKEN FETTUCCINE 21
Smoked chicken, winter squash & greens, Parmesan cheese, white wine cream sauce, handmade fettuccine
PASTA PRIMAVERA 20
Winter squash & greens, fresh herbs, tomato sauce, Parmesan cheese, handmade spaghetti
PORK SCHNITZEL 22
Crispy pork cutlets, pickled red cabbage, herbed spaetzle, caraway seed mustard
*RARE AHI TUNA STEAK WITH A 12 PEPPER BLEND 27
Tuna steak seared rare with a 12-pepper blend, avocado, sesame ginger coleslaw, wasabi aioli, & spicy chili lime sauce
APPETIZERS
HOUSE-MADE MEATBALLS with fresh tomato basil sauce 15
SHRIMP COCKTAIL with jumbo shrimp, cocktail sauce, lemon 18
HAND CUT TRUFFLE FRIES with smoked tomato aioli 11
CHARCUTERIE with artisan meats and cheeses, local honey & apples, pistachios, toasted baguette
STAR DAIRY CHEESE CURDS with peppercorn ranch 12
CRAB RANGOONS with spicy chili lime sauce 12
*RARE AHI TUNA 12 pepper blend with avocado, chili sauce, and wasabi aioli 16
FRENCH ONION SOUP 10
SALADS
Add: chicken 7 4oz top sirloin 14 shrimp 8 pepper crusted ahi tuna 9
ARUGULA BEET SALAD 15
Arugula, beets, goat cheese, pistachios, honey shallot vinaigrette
WEDGE SALAD full 16 or half 10
Iceberg, bacon, tomatoes, hard-boiled egg, blue cheese crumbles, blue cheese dressing
COBB SALAD full 17 or half 11
Smoked chicken, avocado, hard-boiled egg, bacon, tomato, blue cheese crumbles, peppercorn ranch
BLUE CHEESE STEAK SALAD 19
4oz top sirloin, chimichurri, candied pistachios, blue cheese crumbles, red onion, blue cheese dressing
SANDWICHES
PASTRAMI REUBEN 17
House-made pastrami, pickled red cabbage, Swiss cheese, 1000 island, marble rye, hand-cut fries
FRIED CHICKEN, BACON, & RANCH 14
Fried chicken breast, bacon, Swiss cheese, shredded lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing, hand-cut fries
FISH ON A BUN 14
Breaded haddock, tomato, shredded lettuce, tartar sauce, hand-cut fries
*SIMPSON‘S BURGER 14
Shredded lettuce, tomato, red onion, secret sauce, hand-cut fries
Add- Wisconsin cheddar, applewood smoked bacon, avocado, sautéed mushrooms, or grilled onions 2
PRIME RIB FRENCH DIP 18
Shaved prime rib, Swiss cheese, french bread, hand-cut fries
SIMPSON’S TO GO PINTS
COCKTAIL MUSHROOMS 11 SEASONED FLOUR 6 SALAD DRESSINGS 8 GARLIC SPREAD 16
FRESH HORSERADISH 16
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness,
especially if you have certain medical conditions.
A 20% gratuity will be added to parties of 8 or more
corkage & cakeage $10
Share On: